The Ghosts of Gilgo
The public beaches of the south shore of Long Island are among the best in the nation offering wonderful boating, sailing, fishing, swimming and surfing at this moment being enjoyed by many thousands on a sunny June day. One of those beaches, lovely and accessible, is Gilgo.
Gilgo Beach is notorious now for the sex workers whose bodies were found buried there, their rough lives viciously cut short by sick violence between 1993 and 2010.
Last week an ordinary looking 63-year-old architect from Massapequa Park Long Island named Rex Heuermann was sentenced to eight consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole for the murders of eight young women he dumped at Gilgo Beach. Over the last several years the victims' bodies were found mutilated, bound in burlap, sometimes dismembered, and buried in the scrub brush lining the beach.
Although he just pled guilty to the murders of eight women, authorities are not certain that is the extent of his savagery. There could be more victims.
His story brought to mind another Long Island monster, a creep named Joel Rifkin who is currently serving hundreds of years for killing between 15 and 17 sex workers on Long Island, some also dumped on the beach. I interviewed him in a psych ward upstate New York. Rifkin told me that he figured that since he would get the maximum penalty of life for just one murder, anyone over that was a freebie.
Like Rifkin, the story of how the authorities came to suspect Heuermann, and get the evidence needed to convict him is a combination CSI, and old school police work. This banal monster was taken down when authorities matched his DNA from the scene of the crimes, with DNA from the crust of a pizza he discarded in a garbage can outside his Manhattan office building.
Heuermann was still living in in the Massapequa Park neighborhood where he grew up when arrested, in the same home. He was described by neighbors as ordinary, never causing any problems.
Given the chance by presiding Judge Timothy Mazzei to say some last words to a courtroom filled with victimsā families, the killer mumbled, āthe words I would say have no meaning and I'm gonna leave it there.ā
The judge tore into Heuermann. āI know that you're sorry that you got caught. I assume that you're sorry for what you've done to your wife and children. Are you a little bit sorry for what you did to these poor innocent women. Eight women that you strangled to death. You've been described as a very big man. You're a disgusting and despicable small man, if you're a man at all, and you're a cowardā¦get him out of here.ā
Heuermann and Rifkin. Two Long Islanders whose crimes scream out for a return of New York's death penalty.